"Has the Advisory Opinion's Finding that Kosovo's Declaration of Independence was not Contrary to International Law set an Unfortunate Precedent?"

Michigan Law Authors
Publish Date
2015
Publication
The Law and Politics of the Kosovo Advisory Opinion
Publication Type
Book Chapter
Abstract

In the context of Kosovo’s protracted path to formal independence, some political actors have time and again highlighted the sui generis nature of the Kosovo issue, and denied that it would (or should) have any precedential value. Others, on the contrary, precisely relied on the Kosovo ‘precedent’. This chapter analyses the merits of these claims. It concludes that the Advisory Opinion, while not being a precedent in a technical sense, had the unfortunate effect of not containing subsequent (erroneous) reliance on its meagre holdings. With regard to the possible ‘precedential’ value of the DoI and its implicit endorsement by states and the Court, the chapter concludes that the denial of precedential value had the legal effect of stalling the formation of a general opinio juris on secession, but that the legal technique of distinguishing is a sufficient and normatively preferable strategy for containing other instances of imminent secession.

Full Text